Bobby Valentine, the former manager of the New York Mets, recently shared a funny story from 25 years ago during a Q&A session. A 9-year-old fan asked about the time Valentine was ejected from a game and returned to the dugout wearing a fake mustache and sunglasses. This incident, which took place on June 9, 1999, has become legendary among baseball fans.
Valentine explained that he used eye black stickers placed upside down under his nose to create the mustache. When he showed up in the dugout with this disguise, his player Orel Hershiser reassured him that no one would recognize him. However, a camera in the dugout ended up exposing Valentine’s ruse.
The situation arose during a game against the Toronto Blue Jays where Valentine was ejected in the 12th inning for arguing with an umpire. Hershiser suggested that Valentine return to the dugout in disguise to continue managing the team. Despite the comical nature of the incident, Valentine was fined $5,000 and suspended for two games.
Interestingly, Hershiser had seen similar tactics used when he played for the Los Angeles Dodgers under manager Tommy Lasorda. The Mets went on to win the game in the 14th inning thanks to a walk-off hit by Rey Ordóñez, adding to the humor of the situation.
Valentine reflected on the turbulent period leading up to the game, with changes in the coaching staff and concerns about his job security. However, the team rallied and went on to have a successful season, finishing with a 97-66 record.
Despite the passage of time, Valentine is still amused by the story and appreciates the laughter it brings to fans. He emphasized the importance of humor in baseball and how moments like these can bring people together. The incident remains a cherished memory for both Valentine and Hershiser, showcasing the lighter side of the game.
While there have been rumors of Valentine having disguises ready at every stadium, he clarified that this was not the case. The story lives on as a reminder of the fun and camaraderie that can be found in the world of baseball, resonating with fans of all ages.