Two Democratic state attorneys general are facing a lawsuit for allegedly violating the First Amendment by threatening to shut down an organization that provides aid to survivors of sexual assault with a self-administered DNA collection kit. Leda Health Corporation has developed an Early Evidence Kit (EEK) that allows victims to collect DNA evidence at home after a sexual assault. The CEO, Madison Campbell, filed the lawsuit against New York AG Letitia James and Pennsylvania AG Michelle Henry after they expressed opposition to the at-home alternative kit.
The lawsuit claims that the attorneys general threatened, coerced, and intimidated Leda Health to cease its operations in Pennsylvania and New York. The company believes that the Democratic AGs are trying to restrict the information provided to survivors of sexual assault. They argue that victims deserve a broader spectrum of opinions and information, which Leda Health aims to provide.
The attorney representing Campbell emphasized that the lawsuit is about protecting the First Amendment rights of Leda Health and its CEO. The lawsuit alleges that the AGs believe Leda Health cannot inform women about alternatives to government-endorsed services without it being considered a deceptive practice. This restriction on information could hinder survivors from seeking the help they need.
The lawsuit highlights the importance of ensuring that public officials, like attorneys general, respect the First Amendment rights of individuals and corporations. By attempting to interfere in the company’s messaging, the AGs are potentially obstructing efforts to provide better support to victims of sexual assault.
Overall, the lawsuit sheds light on the challenges faced by survivors of sexual assault and the importance of organizations like Leda Health in providing alternative solutions to traditional services. It emphasizes the need to protect the rights of individuals and corporations to convey important information to those in need.
In response to the lawsuit, Letitia James’ office referred to a cease-and-desist letter sent to Leda Health in 2019 regarding their kits. The office of Michelle Henry has not yet commented on the matter. It is essential to consider the implications of restricting information and support for survivors of sexual assault and ensure that all legal avenues are explored to address these obstacles.
